Sep
11

Has workers comp “managed care” worked in Ohio?

The Cleveland Plain Dealer has published an article that is highly critical of Ohio’s workers comp managed care program. The analysis performed by the paper (and subsequently reported by AP and other news outlets) notes that administrative costs associated with claims management have gone up much faster than the rate of inflation,while medical costs have experienced a similar trend.
Several other papers inside and outside Ohio are also focusing on the BWC managed care program.

Continue reading Has workers comp “managed care” worked in Ohio?


Sep
11

HMOs cost less because they pay less

HMOs are cheaper than other forms of health insurance due to lower provider costs. At least that’s what an analysis of a 2004 study comparing HMOs to other forms of insurance discussed by Jason Shafrin in a post on Healthcare Economist says.
The difference amounted to 9.3%, with no measurable difference in utilization rates or risk selection between HMOs and other plans.
So, as an industry, HMOs are not more efficient because they are better at managing care or selecting risk, they are cheaper because they pay providers less. I would note that the analysis is based on data from the nineties, so perhaps a more accurate statement is that in the past HMOs were more efficient.
I don’t know if that’s the case today.


Sep
10

Part D – where next?

Part D’s implications will be many, far-reaching, and complex. Why? the sheer size of the market…One-twelfth of all scripts dispensed in retail pharmacies were for Part D recipients.
Here’s a snapshot of the crystal ball.

Continue reading Part D – where next?


Sep
7

HWR 15 is up at InsureBlog

Hank Stern and Bob Vineyard of InsureBlog have prepared a virtual cornucopia of health wonk delights. Their edition of Health Wonk Review is indeed serious brain food. No reservations required, come as you are, and buon apetit’!


Sep
7

P&C Insurance – So far, so good…so far

Projections for insurer profits this year are looking pretty rosy, at least according to Fitch Ratings. For most property and casualty insurers, profits are up over last year at this time, losses are down, and premium growth continues to trend slightly upward as well.
As always, profits are only as solid as tomorrow’s weather forecast, and few insurance execs think they’re out of the woods yet.

Continue reading P&C Insurance – So far, so good…so far


Sep
6

Ohio’s work comp scandal’s ugly tentacles

The mess, and it is a real mess, that is the Ohio Bureau of Workers Compensation scandal has spread its ugly tentacles. The latest is the innuendo that the present head of the North Dakota state workers comp insurer has been unfairly linked to one of the accused felons involved in the Ohio BWC corruption. (ND is a monopolistic state, where WC insurance is only available from the state itself).
I have no personal knowledge of the ND fund situation, but find it most distressing that an individual who once had the misfortune to work with one of the sleazy officials in Ohio would be somehow tainted by that link.
Fortunately, an upcoming audit report will provide an objective review of the ND fund’s operations (link is the past report, new report is due shortly) and results. Here’s hoping that it finds nothing even close to the swamp of misdeeds and corruption that was Ohio’s BWC.


Sep
6

McClellan’s legacy

Mark McClellan is leaving his post as head of the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services. He served long and loyally, sticking to the Administration’s line even when facts indicated otherwise, remaining a calming force when Part D enrollment was going nowhere. McClellan is also known for listening hard to suggestions and criticism from all sides, and working diligently to address problems.
Here’s what’s happened during his tenure.
Part D was passed, implemented, and operational. This was a monumental task, and one McClellan was instrumental in accomplishing. It’s not his fault it is a fatally flawed program; well, maybe it is, in some small part, as he was probably involved in writing/editing/opining on the legislation. Nevertheless, under McClellan the program became reality, with the initial enrollment problems addressed (in large part).

Continue reading McClellan’s legacy


Sep
5

HWR submissions due

Hank Stern and associates at Insure Blog are awaiting your submission for this week’s edition of Health Wonk Review.
I know it’s the first day back from vacation, I also know it’s time to get busy building traffic! Send your entry to Hank at InsureBlog@hotmail.com.


Sep
1

The uninsured – wide variation among states

The bad news is the number of those without health insurance in the US has grown to over 46 million. The good news is that a few states have seen a reduction in the number of uninsured; the really bad news is a few have gotten even worse.
Several states are doing well. One is Iowa, where the uninsured population actually decreased last year, as the percentage of those without health insurance dropped from 10.4% in 2004 to 9.1% in 2005. Part of this success is due to increased enrollment of kids in the state’s Hawk-I program, which more than doubled over five years to 34,600 in 2005. This parallels an increase of 200,000 enrolled in various government-funded programs over the same period.
Maine’s one of the better off states, with a population of uninsured that is significantly lower (10.5%) than the national average of 15.7%. The state’s Dirigo health plan, an effort to increase coverage among Mainers by targeting small employers and kids, has failed to meet enrollment goals but generated significant savings. It is tough to tell if the program has had an impact on the uninsured rate, as it is very new.
One that is not experiencing the same level of success is Arizona, with 20% of the population uninsured after an increase of 225,000 in the number of uninsured in 2005. To address the problem, the state is seeking to implement a revamped Medicaid program under a Federal waiver that focuses on the lower-income workers employed at businesses with fewer than 25 employees. There are over 200,000 businesses in the state that meet the size criterion.
As bad as the situation is in Arizona, it is worse in Texas, where almost a quarter of the population lacks health insurance.
What does this mean for you?
A closer examination of individual states may help us understand drivers of and solutions to the problem of uninsurance.


Aug
30

Aetna’s new workers comp PBM

With the news that Aetna has entered into the work comp pharmacy benefit management business, there are now officially a bazillion WC PBMs doing business. Maybe even two bazillion.
Aetna has been in and out of the WC business in the past, and now appears to be in it, at least as a managed care vendor. Aetna Workers Comp Access is the brand name for the company’s PPO network, one that is gaining some traction in certain jurisdictions. The new PBM venture appears to be an attempt to use Aetna’s group health-oriented PBM to deliver drugs to comp patients. But the WC PBM business is much much different than group health. There are no deductibles or copays in comp, identifying the patient’s PBM is much more of a challenge, and the country is a crazy quilt of different regulations, as each state sets its own rules, reimbursement levels, and operating standards.
The strategy is to cross sell the PBM to Aetna’s (group health) employer clients. One of the touted benefits is the ability to identify potentially harmful drug interactions across both group health and WC medical treatment. Aetna has landed their first customer, CostCo, and are also bidding on carrier business (several of the larger insurers have been or are out to bid for PBM services).
Aetna is not doing this on their own, but has contracted with Rockville, MD based CatalystRx to provide the WC expertise needed to operate in the comp market. This is a somewhat puzzling choice; Catalyst is not a big player in WC and does not have a lot of experience in the space. Their contribution will be key if Aetna’s newest venture is to become a viable option for comp drug buyers.
What does this mean for you?
Another option in the already-crowded WC PBM industry, albeit one with a different twist.