« Personal responsibility and health care costs | Main | Who's buying CorVel? »

I'm so done with consumerism

The problem with consumer-directed health plans as presently constructed is fundamental.

They will not work.

They miss the target entirely, mis-understand the problem, and, if taken seriously, will distract from getting to a real solution.

On the other hand, when they fail miserably, as they inevitably will, we'll be in such bad shape that a radical revision of the health care system may well be possible.

Thanks to Graham for the reminder...

Posted by on December 4, 2006 7:17 AM |

Comments

Joe, I've felt all along that the path to both lower HC costs and better outcomes is better patient management of chronic disease risks. Advocates of CDHP never seem to articulate that. Shame on them. But chronic conditions are much less expensive if treated preventively, and then managed, and if patient involvement is crtical, then I don't think we should pour the concept down the toilet -- yet.

Posted by: Peter Rousmaniere | December 5, 2006 12:57 PM

Joe,

Thanks for the discussion of this. I am really annoyed that the solution to so many problems seems to be to throw them back on the consumer. I have a hard enough time trying to choose a cell phone plan. I do not want to have to become an expert in health insurance too.

Posted by: Ed Keer | December 15, 2006 2:15 PM

Post a comment

Due to the growing number of spam comments, I have to ask you to do one more thing to get your comment posted. Just type in the text you see in the box below into the textbox to the right. That will prove you are a real human and not a computer system that is posting spam. Please be careful to enter in the right code; if you make a mistake the system may temporarily block you. If the authentication system is blocking you, try again in an hour. If you continue to be blocked, send your comment to jpaduda AT healthstrategyassoc DOT com and note that you would like your comment posted. Thanks.