Joseph Paduda's weblog on managed care for group health, workers compensation & auto insurance, covering health care cost containment, health policy, health research, and medical news for insurers, employers, and healthcare providers.

« Off to Vegas! | Main | Las Vegas - the sort-of perfect analogy for workers comp »

the comp conference - first impression

before I even hit the floor (exhibit, that is), it became evident that the big thing this year is...MSAs!

Really.

For those of us who were under the impression that the Medicare set-aside business had peaked some time ago, it looks like a lot of folks were reading the tea leaves differently. With "a lot" defined as seventeen.

There are no fewer than 17 vendors that list MSAs (of something very close to that) in the conference guidebook. Most sell other services as well, a few specialize in MSAs, and there are a couple law firms that do the legal work part of the MSA process.

With that much competition, it's pretty apparent the MSA business is fast becoming commoditized, with prices likely falling rapidly. Sources indicate Coventry has been hit hard, and ha recently shut down an MSA office, laid off some of the staff, and transferred the remaining work to another Coventry location. This may well be an astute decision as competing in a commodity market is not a good long term tactic for any but the most focused, and Coventry's attention is clearly elsewhere.

For those just entering the fray, get efficient quickly, deliver great customer service, don't overpromise or commit to things you don't control (eg acceptance by CMS) and communicate well and often with adjusters. And be prepared for shrinking margins.

Comments

Joe:

While I often enjoy reading your managed care blog and even the occasional political rant, your analysis of the MSA business is generally off base.

While it is true there are many companies that have hung an MSA shingle over the last several years(see www.medvalblog.com "MSA Goldrush"), the same 7-10 firms control 90% of the market. Furthermore, MSAs are far from a commodity product like PBM or bill review. Good MSA firms understand the complexity of insurance settlements and provide expertise and value that does not exist in the market at large. Payers that look at MSAs as a commodity and are focused soley on price or sales gimmicks are likely overpaying for their claims and achieving subpar results.

Just because you put MSA services on your trade show display doesn't mean you are in the MSA business.

Ryan Roth
MEDVAL, LLC

Post a comment

Due to the growing number of spam comments, I have to ask you to do one more thing to get your comment posted. Just type in the text you see in the box below into the textbox to the right. That will prove you are a real human and not a computer system that is posting spam. Please be careful to enter in the right code; if you make a mistake the system may temporarily block you. If the authentication system is blocking you, try again in an hour. If you continue to be blocked, send your comment to jpaduda AT healthstrategyassoc DOT com and note that you would like your comment posted. Thanks.

Joseph Paduda is the principal of Health Strategy Associates.

Get notified by e-mail about site updates:

March 2009

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30 31
Powered by
Movable Type 3.33