Insight, analysis & opinion from Joe Paduda

< Back to Home


The trade “war” and workers’ comp

Responding to the European Union’s new import tariffs, Harley Davidson will be shifting some production from American factories to its plants in Brazil, India, and Thailand in an effort to keep it’s bikes affordable.

A store in Paris

Motorcycles aren’t the only US product suffering from the not-quite-yet-a-trade war. Orange juice, cranberry juice, peanut butter, bourbon, tobacco products, steel, jeans, and playing cards are among those that are incurring at least 25% import duties.

Farmers and those in the “food chain” may be the next to feel the pain. In response to Trump’s tariffs, Beijing has said that it will retaliate by imposing duties of fifteen per cent on a wide range of American foodstuffs, According to the New Yorker the products affected include: “soybeans, cashews, almonds, apricots, strawberries, and other fruits. Pork products, which are very popular in China, would be hit with a tariff of twenty-five per cent.”

Harley-Davidson’s move was driven by the European Union’s increase of import duties, aka tariffs by 25%. This was in response to President Trump’s higher import duties on certain EU products.  With the new EU tariff raising prices by an average of $2200 per bike, HD management is now eating the losses in order to keep market share in Europe until the company can ramp up production overseas; this quote from HD is from The New Yorker:

“Increasing international production to alleviate the EU tariff burden is not the company’s preference, but represents the only sustainable option to make its motorcycles accessible to customers in the EU and maintain a viable business in Europe,”

Farm products have already been hit by trade war fears; corn and soybean futures are at a two-year low. While there’s a lot driving those prices, the short-term outlook for farmers, wholesalers, farm-equipment manufacturers and others in the ag value chain are not good.

China buys over $20 billion of US agricultural products every year, and is moving to buy more from Brazil and other countries as US goods will be much more expensive with the import duties.

Our neighbor has 1300 acres of soybeans and corn, so this is pretty real to us.

One company that’s getting hit from both sides in this trade thing is John Deere. The company’s steel prices are up while future demand for its products – both here and overseas – is in doubt. According to one analyst,

Deere & Company could end up seeing years of depressed US agricultural sales, because it may take farming households years to recover financially.

So, what does this have to do with workers’ comp?

Insurers and employers are enjoying the latest in a string of really, really good years. 2017’s combined ratio was a stellar 89, the best result we’ve seen in two decades. While premiums were down marginally last year, the pre-tax operating margin hit 23 percent, a level we haven’t seen in recent memory.

All this really really good news has been driven by a nine-year long recovery, a continuation in the structural decrease in claim frequency (and likely total claims), and relatively low medical inflation.

The very strong labor market helps a lot; re-employing injured workers is a lot easier when there are lots of job openings and employers work really hard to get injured workers back on the job to meet demand.

One would do well to remember what happens when good things come to an end. Claims jump up, possibly driven by workers scared of layoffs deciding to report that nagging pain. Employers stop hiring, afraid to be stuck with lots of idle workers when demand drops off.

If the current trade conflict gets any more heated, we’re headed for a nasty trade war, one that will have deep and lasting effects on every sector from steel to transport to agriculture to tourism.

What does this mean for you?

Trade wars will hurt the economy and hammer workers’ comp insurers. Companies serving the claims sector may well see an uptick as claim frequency and claim duration increase.



3 thoughts on “The trade “war” and workers’ comp”

Comments are closed.

Joe Paduda is the principal of Health Strategy Associates




A national consulting firm specializing in managed care for workers’ compensation, group health and auto, and health care cost containment. We serve insurers, employers and health care providers.



© Joe Paduda 2019. We encourage links to any material on this page. Fair use excerpts of material written by Joe Paduda may be used with attribution to Joe Paduda, Managed Care Matters.

Note: Some material on this page may be excerpted from other sources. In such cases, copyright is retained by the respective authors of those sources.